Why Has Grayling Banned Books?

AtoZ ChallengeA-Z Challenge letter: G – Grayling



Minister for Employment Rt Hon Chris Grayling ...Towards the end of last month, I read an article on Politics.co.uk about Justice Secretary Chris Grayling’s decision to ban prisoners have books sent in from “outside”. Any book. Any prisoner.

There have been many rule changes made regarding prisoners recently, apparently to encourage compliance with prison rules. But since the ban on books applies to all prisoners, no matter how well behaved, I can’t see how this can be an incentive to follow the rules.

In a modern, “civilised” society, the purpose of sending offenders to prison is supposed to be less about wanting to exact a pound of flesh and more about encouraging a change of behaviour. One of the things that can work well is helping prisoners achieve qualifications or develop skills which will help them in the future. Banning books (and specialist interest magazines) being sent in for prisoners limits their ability to do this. Prisons have libraries of course, but as funding is cut, so too are the facilities provided to prisons.

Banning books seems to me to be a peculiar kind of punishment, and a dangerous one, for practical and ideological reasons.

Philip PullmanAuthors from Mark Haddon to Ruth Padel, Philip Pullman to Ian Rankin have criticised the move, with Haddon beginning a petition to have the decision reversed.

“It reminds me of the Greek junta: and even worse dictatorships. Is this government going to ban books for the people who need them most?”

Ruth Padel

The Justice Ministry has defended the decision saying that the  ban on books being sent to prisoners by families and friends is part of a new “incentives and earned privileges” regime, introduced last November, which allows prisoners access to funds to buy books and other items as they move up from “basic” level.

If you would like to sign the petition, you can find it here.



Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Why Has Grayling Banned Books?

  1. I have mixed feelings about this one, I use to work in a young offenders unit. A paperback can be sent in, passed as ok. But when it’s put in water – magic mushrooms would grow from it. It had been subjected to the spores. Nice to connect and follow through a to z http://aimingforapublishingdeal.blogspot.co.uk/

  2. It’s difficult, because I don’t agree that prisoners should be able to just get things for no reason, they should be earned. So I understand that concept, as long as they can earn the money to get the books with I think that’s fairly reasonable.

  3. If anything should be banned – it’s TV and bloomin’ playstations or x boxes that they get in their rooms.

  4. I actually don’t think it is as straightforward as just banning books, as ever the media love to blow stories right out of the open.

%d bloggers like this: